Bitwarden not working in Vanadium / Brave

onyourbikes

BHydden it doesn't work properly. It just allows you to jump to the app and then copy the data. That you then have to manually switch back to vanadium and paste it.

I'm 99% sure it used to work perfectly where it would autofill but stopped when android 13 was released.

BHydden

onyourbikes works perfectly for me too not sure what your problem is

doffactory

It works for me. To write this message I just had to log in and used bitwarden for it with autofill.

Eirikr70

Same here. Works perfectly !

user

I have the same problem. To my knowledge Bitwarden autofill doesn't work on brave and vanadium without accessibility services enabled which are a security risk. It works however on bromite without the need of accessibility on.

Orphee

user same for me too.
Works one Firefox

jultaholtu

user

Sorry for asking, might not be the right thread, but wanted to know anyway :)
What is the 'security risk' with accessibility services enabled? I have it enabled?

Thanks!

user

jultaholtu

the vast permissions and control that accessibility has on the phone

akc3n

jultaholtu What is the 'security risk' with accessibility services enabled? I have it enabled?

Explained here:
https://twitter.com/GrapheneOS/status/1583574976506253312 | nitter

spiral

There is some problem with password managers and Chromium browsers.

akc3n

It does support them but not via the native autofill support in the OS. Chromium and therefore also Vanadium currently only support the Play services autofill library. It would be nice to get this resolved upstream in Chromium instead of maintaining it ourselves.

https://twitter.com/GrapheneOS/status/1584129128034205696 | nitter

BHydden

akc3n hmm I wonder which is the bigger security risk. Letting BitWarden have accessibility privilege or passing all your passwords through the clipboard... would prefer to keep using Vanadium and BitWarden. I feel like clipboard is worse than accessibility.

mer1od9

Apart from this, lack of auto-fill makes users more exposed to phishing attacks

[deleted]

mer1od9 no, use chrome and Google password manager!

spiral

FYI, when using firefox there are no problems with autofill using KeepassDX nor with Bitwarden

freedom_warrior

spiral brave for android doesn't support inline autofill. Its on them

spiral

freedom_warrior
Huh? I posted that like 16 months ago and afaict I never brought up Brave

[deleted]

[deleted] Why not KeypassDX? It's autofill works.

[deleted]

[deleted] because with google you can properly secure your account and you can add a synchronization password if you don't trust google. then why google, because on chrome you don't need to enter your login to connect.

roamer4223

I am very confused here. I use Vanadium, the default keyboard, and Bitwarden. I also do not have Play Services installed and I do not use the accessibility service. I only use the android autofill framework.

Why is the Bitwarden autofill working for me absolutely fine? It appears just under the box that needs to be filled with a suggestion of what accounts to use, I tap it and it works on 99% websites I use, including this one.

I am using a pixel 8 pro though I believe it also works fine on 6a and 6 pro.

Very confused....

Relaks

roamer4223 Same for me. It has always worked fine since they added Vanadium support. Although I do use Play Services, I don't see how it should be needed. It does not autofill in Brave for me, so I can confirm that. Pixel 6a.