I had a second device (Redmi Note 9S) that runs crDroid...
I have tried to logout from Revolut app (10.58.2) then re-login with no issues.
I think crDroid is spoofing anything that ables to login into Revolut and maybe in other apps.
Can this hack be included in GrapheneOS as an option?
schklom
There are probably 2 or 3 hundred thousand total GOS users but only a tiny fraction of that number actually needs and uses that particular banking app. No one from North America, for instance, would need it. One or two hundred is a wild guess. Of course, I don't know the actual number but it's pretty small in the grand scheme of things.
cdflasdkesalkjfkdfkjsdajfd Can this hack be included in GrapheneOS as an option?
This question has arisen before, and the official response has been that it doesn't make sense to add spoofing code that is already becoming less useful (as more apps switch to Play Integrity) and is scheduled to stop working soon when Google turns off the previous system (source).
BuffaloStance
oK, I stand corrected but I stand by my premise that there just aren't enough users, really anywhere, for them to justify making changes. You, and dozens of other Americans use Revolut, I guess.
Not unlike Whatsapp, Revolut is wildly popular the absolute market leader in its realm abroad while barely an afterthought here in the states. Still, "dozens" is a gross underestimate. Maybe you meant dozens of US based GOS users use Revolut. In that case, I concur. Your point remains understood, either way and you are right about the lacking demand.
Personally, I only use Revolut bc their currency transfer rates are unmatched...by a wide margin, in fact. Super beneficial for frequent/extended international travel.
de0u Have you red this? It seems a official answer by GrapheneOS...
We're going to be adding a toggle for blocking the Play Integrity API in a way that acts as if the service is currently down. We've found that many apps do not correctly use it and still allow using the app if it's unavailable because their service only has soft enforcement of the Play Integrity API. It's possible this will be enough to get Revolut working but we don't know at this point. They're going out of the way to try banning using alternate OSes and can upgrade that over time.
cdflasdkesalkjfkdfkjsdajfd Have you [read] this?
Yes. That wouldn't be spoofing code in the sense of faking a result (it would be a non-result). And if it's implemented I'll be surprised if it works for more than three months. But my skepticism might turn out to be wrong!
For those looking for an alternative, N26 currently works on gOS, still isn't really as good as Revolut though.
RESOLVED. The current REVOLUT version of in Aurora detects graphenOS and does not let it run, this is a problem I hope the GrapheneOS people fix it because other apps can be updated and stop working in GrapheneOS.
To fix it, you only need to install the previous version 10.52.1
Cheers.
Jirafa And does that version actually let you sign in and use the app actively without forcing you to upgrade to a newer version? 10.52.1 is an even older version than 10.54, which is now blocked from being used after you have signed in.
And even if it does work now, it would be wise to not rely on it to keep working into the future. They are almost definitely going to ban older versions from being used to connect to their servers in the future.
Jirafa In the end, this is just an artificial extension of life. The machines still work but the brain has long been dead. How long will this work with old versions...
Jirafa We can't fix apps going out of the way to ban using GrapheneOS. It's not a technical problem or something missing on GrapheneOS. It's these apps using the Play Integrity API to ban using any aftermarket OS or device not certified by Google. It's highly anti-competitive and clearly illegal but happening anyway. Regulators and courts move slowly and don't have much technical knowledge. Google is trying to mask it as being for security purposes to justify the anti-competitive behavior. People shouldn't fall for it. Permitting a device with no security patches for 8 years but banning a far more secure OS than the most secure one they permit (stock Pixel OS) is clearly not a security-based decision. They provide no way for GrapheneOS to be permitted and most of what companies have to comply with to be certified is not security related but rather Google defending their monopolies and overall business interests.
You can't do that without first uninstalling the app, because of Android's downgrade protection. The info you're replying to is outdated and Revolut now blocks using version 10.54 and probably older versions as well. The recent report of an even older version than that now suddenly working isn't clear.
GrapheneOS So what keeps you guys going?
It looks like you're staring at your fade away as we speak...
pirron4 overall, only a small number of apps are not working on GrapheneOS because of Play Integrity and more may follow, but it's hardly the end of the OS, so please don't act like it is.
As the project account has said, what Google is doing is illegal and the project is talking regulators in the EU. Here's a quote:
United States v. Google LLC (2020) recently found that Google's Android partner system and therefore the Play Integrity API based on it is illegal.
We're in active contact with the EU Commission about the Play Integrity API and are hopeful they're going to do something about it.
other8026 overall, only a small number of apps are not working on GrapheneOS because of Play Integrity and more may follow, but it's hardly the end of the OS, so please don't act like it is.
As the project account has said, what Google is doing is illegal and the project is talking regulators in the EU. Here's a quote:
This is the Gordian knot that needs to be cut. But the mills of bureaucracy grind slowly, very slowly... so we have to wait and see what will be faster in the end: The bureaucracy or the app makers who will go for Play Integrity.
It certainly won't be or become the end of the project, but the critical mass of apps will contribute significantly to the future.
Sorry, that's not a black painting, but unfortunately you can't sugarcoat it either.
