pascalw In the meantime I've contacted DigiD and the first response was "We don't support GrapheneOS, only Android is supported.". Let's see if I can make it through to their 2nd line support.
Any luck so far? I've sent a reply asking whether the fault is due to Google Mobile Vision (and that it is deprecated) and asking for the use of open source libraries.
I have send emails repeatedly to the developers of DigID well over a year ago (Logius), and they have never even bothered to respond.
The app used to work - including scanning QR codes - around a year ago (without Google play services!). Eventually an update caused it to break. I avoided updating as long as possible but eventually the old version I had was deprecated and did no longer work because it was too old.
It's a shame that apps like this are dependent on third party services and that it doesn't work natively.
Nice to see fellow people from the Netherlands using GrapheneOS btw, we're one of few and I personally don't know anyone else that uses GOS.
Best of luck with getting through to Logius!
They have asked me to email them with my BSN and a phone number they can reach me on, so they can get more information. I may email them to check what they will say. I wasn't aware of Logius, pretty bad they don't bother to respond...
You can try contacting Logius here, maybe that'll work. https://logius.nl/contact/formulieren/algemeen-contactformulier
The app works for me on the latest version 6.5.4 but I'm not sure it was because of that. It looks like FireFox wasn't generating the QR code image correctly when compared to Chrome... is this what others have noticed as well?
finitefutility Working for me as well.
For your Firefox, if it looks like a weird colored blob thingy then u should be able to fix that in the firefox settings I had that as well a while ago. Has something to do with the privacy settings and fingerprinting I believe.
Uphill1945 Thanks for pointing that out, I had to disable privacy.resistFingerprinting in about:config for it to work now. Left the other default fingerprinting settings enabled (as default).
@finitefutility just double checking; scanning the Digid QR codes with the app now works for you? I'm on 6.5.4 and it's still not working for me, no matter which desktop browser I use. I'm running without (sandboxed) Google Play Services though.
I had the same issue with QR codes not being scanned. After installing sandboxed Google Play, the issue disappears. Network Access for at least one of the 3 Google Play apps is required. My test was with Network Access disabled first for all 3. When that didn't work, I enabled access for all three, and it started working.
I was hoping to avoid Google Play all together, but it looks like I found my first reason to start using User Profiles.
This is a step in the right direction: https://github.com/MinBZK/woo-besluit-broncode-digid-app. Source code is published now, though it's a snapshot and not meant to accept contributions.
Relevant source code is here, which indeed relies on GMS: https://github.com/MinBZK/woo-besluit-broncode-digid-app/blob/master/Source/DigiD.Droid/Views/QRCodeDetectionView.cs
pascalw hey yeah it works but I do have Google Play Service set up...
And mildly enjoying how they were forced to publish a snapshot of their code... Glad to see transparency requests can sometimes work in government!
Indeed it works with Network Access enabled:
Have you guys noticed that when you enable Camera permission -> Ask every time in the DigiD app, the app doesn't prompt you for camera access if the Google services above are enabled?
Is this still the case? or was it (hopefully) fixed?
Dby6 works perfectly fine
Another DigiD user here ;) Ran into the same issue, DigiD only seems to scan QR codes when all three Google service apps are running with network permissions enabled. I would have not figured this out without this thread, so thanks!
I came up with this workflow btw:
It's not ideal, but it works. Anyway, nothing that GrapheneOS can fix I'm afraid. Really hope DigiD changes their QR scanner to not rely on the Google services in the future...
Network access is required in order for the Google Play Store to download dynamite modules for Google Play services, including the machine learning vision module. They aren't using a Google service to scan QR codes but rather a Google library that's downloaded dynamically. If you disabled network access after the fact, it would likely work fine, but you would be blocking updates to dynamite modules. Disabling Network access for Google Play only intermittently is problematic since it will download and use dynamite modules while you have it granted and then you've blocked it from updating them. If you're enabling Network access intermittently for apps, you aren't getting the benefits of it. Apps are designed to queue up all their network requests until they have network access again. Therefore, toggling it on and off based on when it's needed doesn't improve privacy in the way that many people wrongly think it would. There's a reason it doesn't have an "Allow while in use" option like Camera, Microphone, etc. although in theory it could be added, but it would be misleading.
This should be fixed now! 🎉
https://www.digitaleoverheid.nl/nieuws/digid-app-nu-ook-op-android-zonder-google-qr-code-scanner/
Confirmed working in build 6.9.3.
Hello, another Dutchman here. Since some 1 or 2 months I cannot use the QR code scanning of the Digid-app, whereas it used to work flawlessly.
I have tried this with GSF and Play Store and Play services all with Network-access.
It still does not work: no response in Digid to a QR code.
Any suggestions for me to test further? Thanks!
