Hi Graphene team,

Mishaal Rahman of XDA has successfully tested building Android 13 with the old Settings provider model re-enabled, which allows for separate Wifi and Cellular toggles in Quick Settings. The relevant code is a 2 line patch to platform_frameworks_base in Graphene.

Many thanks if this could be enabled in Android 13. Android 12 allowed users to opt-in to the old model via ADB; the code is unmaintained but as long as it works, the option is much appreciated.

As to why?

The new Internet tile doesn't obviously show connection state at a glance.
The popup it triggers is poorly designed upstream; if you toggle wifi, the whole popup expands and moves the toggles so it's not intuitive to use.
It's reasonable for a security-focused OS to show all active radios directly in the quick settings at a glance, which could be relevant to user's threat models.
Lots of people prefer having the Android <=11 tiles :).

There's two open source apps which somewhat work around this with severe limitations:

Wifi QS which adds a Wifi Toggle only. (Note: To have it show the SSID, manually allow "Always" location permission).
Better Internet Tiles which does both, but requires root or Shizuku, which can both impact the GrapheneOS security model. Also, has Google tracking code (GMS and Firebase Crashlytics).