The idea that a banking app can block a certain group of it users from access to most of its services is a serious issue.
I am glad to see that the community is coming together to work against such a change. I hope that this issue will be overcome quickly and I that we can get as many people in contact with their support team as possible.
skipit It was probably caught by an automated filter and flagged as an ad. You could try appealing the blockage like the email says. Another user's post was flagged but they appealed and it was allowed after a human reviewed it.
In general, the sentence "does not support" might benefit from being replaced by something akin to "started blocking being used on Pixel devices that are running GrapheneOS". Strictly speaking Revolut has never "supported" GrapheneOS, which is what their support staff keep repeating, but it has never outright blocked it until now.
Also, pretty sure that you can leave the beta temporarily, reopen Play Store, post a review that is then made public, then rejoin the beta.
I have posted a 1-star review with my complaints as well. Let's keep pushing this and hopefully they will revert the decision.
However I think this will just gain us some time. Imo the permanent solution would be developing cryptocurrencies to the point were they are actually usable for daily lives. This instance with Revolut just highlights how easy it is for banks to block your money if they don't agree with something you are doing. We need truly free money.
1rainyday Imo the permanent solution would be developing cryptocurrencies to the point were they are actually usable for daily lives.
That would be nice, but I won't see it happening ever.
So we need to fight for our right to use traditional banking on an operating system that doesn't spy on us! And without mandatory Google or Apple accounts!
In the same boat as you...
The answer I got from an human representative (not a *** chatbot):
Thank you for the information. Revolut does not accept devices with custom firmware, such as GrapheneOS, which is likely why you're experiencing this issue. I recommend trying to access your Revolut account from a device with a standard Android operating system that is not running custom firmware. You can also try logging in using your email or phone number associated with your Revolut account on a compatible device.
Carbon14 this answer is copypaste from the OK me I've received a few days ago
That's realistically never going to happen in first-world countries, at least not in our lifetimes, unless said first-world countries get poorer and poorer and poorer
What would happen in your opinion if first world countries get poorer? More people switching to crypto to combat inflation?
So we need to fight for our right to use traditional banking on an operating system that doesn't spy on us! And without mandatory Google or Apple accounts!
To me that seems like a even harder battle wrt using crypto. The traditional banking system doesn't want you to have full control on your money. That is how they make money. I don't expect mass widespread adoption of crypto to happen anytime soon, but I still hope that more and more parallel circular economies based on crypto will spring up, so that the people who wants to can opt out.
Btw, I just installed Revolut 10.58.2 and I am still able to access the app. Do you guys think it is possible that the restriction is applied only to new logins? I guess if they know that you have been using a custom firmware until now, it doesn't make any sense to block you?
1rainyday Do you guys think it is possible that the restriction is applied only to new logins?
They don't block users who are already logged in, as evidenced by the users in this thread, the community chat rooms, Twitter, Mastodon, etc. They block new logins and signups.
1rainyday I guess if they know that you have been using a custom firmware until now, it doesn't make any sense to block you?
We don't know the logic behind this. Maybe there is one, maybe there isn't. If Revolut were serious about protecting users against using an insecure OS, why wouldn't they block those users from accessing the app entirely? If they believe that you're using an insecure OS that could put your assets at risk, it makes rationally more sense to block that threat immediately, rather than waiting for you to sign out manually.
I really don't understand the Revolut move.
Why ill do not simply adds a message at the login process to let know the user that the app is running in a "unsecure" OS and let the user to decide if continue using the app or not? At the end is the user money the one in risk!
Viewpoint0232 we need to fight for our right to use traditional banking on an operating system that doesn't spy on us!
Amen
1rainyday The traditional banking system doesn't want you to have full control on your money.
What's at stake in this thread is mostly about convenience vs surveillance, not control of money.
A person can control their Revolut money like normal on a stock Android or iOS device.
That control is not at risk (in the context of this thread, at least).
What's at stake in this thread is:
the convenience of having just 1x daily driver device that can handle all desired apps, with minimal surveillance.
vs
the inconvenience of using 2x phones to handle all desired apps, one GOS and one stock/iOS, with the extra surveillance that implies.
1rainyday Imo the permanent solution would be developing cryptocurrencies to the point were they are actually usable for daily lives.
1rainyday I still hope that more and more parallel circular economies based on crypto will spring up
This is off topic, but -
Obligatory link
https://www.web3isgoinggreat.com/
A person can control their Revolut money like normal on a stock Android or iOS device.
That control is not at risk (in the context of this thread, at least).
I see your point, but at the same time this fact made me reflect on how easily a bank can block access to your funds if they really want to... I am looking at the problem at a more systemic level. But I agree it is indeed off-topic.
Yeah there are a lot of scams in crypto, but that doesn't mean much. It is like saying GrapheneOS is insecure because there are a ton of crappy phones with terrible security around.
cdflasdkesalkjfkdfkjsdajfd I really don't understand the Revolut move.
Why ill do not simply adds a message at the login process to let know the user that the app is running in a "unsecure" OS and let the user to decide if continue using the app or not? At the end is the user money the one in risk!
Just a guess - they are probably using some 3rd party solution that detects "insecure devices" and bails out. If this is true, it probably makes sense to find out which one they use and talk to developers of that solution, convincing them that GrapheneOS is secure, and not to Revolut.
traveller you cannot. Only Revolut, if pays for the change, can
Has anyone tried installing Revolut from Huawei's App Gallery? Some banks may publish their apps there, and change them to work without Play Services. You may need to install Huawei Mobile Services too so that you can guarantee compatibility with what apps installed from there may expect. I had another bank app that worked this way, but I switched to Play Store's version once it worked again.
somerandomdude Has anyone tried installing Revolut from Huawei's App Gallery?
I just did, and can tell you that it pops up the exact same warning message about keeping my data ""secure"" as the version from Play Store. (I did make sure to uninstall any previously installed package first).
I have just received official response to my complaint. The important parts:
In your formal complaint, you expressed your dissatisfaction with a recent update to the Revolut app for Android, as you are not able to access the Revolut app on your phone which runs on GrapheneOS. You stated that no prior notification was given about the change, it is inconsistently implemented, there is lack of transparency on why the OS has been blocked and users who are already logged in are unaffected by the change. To resolve this, you requested to provide a detailed explanation of why Graphene OS is unsupported, and whether Revolut plans to address this issue in the near future.
I sincerely regret the inconvenience caused by this situation, and having looked into your case, I would like to provide you with some additional information on the matter at hand.
Please allow me to emphasise that Revolut strives to provide industry best security standards and the best user experience for our application. The safety of our customers’ accounts and funds is paramount to us. Therefore, we have required our customers to keep their application and the software for their mobile devices up to date and we currently support official Android OS and iOS only.
This information is outlined in Clause 5 of our , where it reads:
<..>To help keep your account safe, download the latest software for your mobile device and the latest version of the Revolut app as soon as they are available.<..>
Please note that with each operating system update, Revolut also needs to provide updates in order to keep our app fully functional and secure. We frequently roll-out updates from time to time, and with each update, features and security updates are applied. Hence, the update can not be reversed.
I would like to note that GrapheneOS has never been fully supported, although it may have worked with the Revolut app in the past. Regrettably, there are currently no plans to introduce support for GrapheneOS in the foreseeable future.
I understand this situation has put you in a frustrating position, which is definitely not the experience we would like for our customers.
Even though we always work to get the best outcome for our customers, the extent of our abilities does not always correspond to what our customer wants us to do. Our intention is always to provide clear and transparent information regarding our services and features, and that all the relevant information can be consulted at any time by our customers.Nonetheless, we highly value your feedback and I can assure you that our Product team is aware of the limitations for GrapheneOS users. We will use your feedback to continuously improve our services where possible. We appreciate your understanding in this matter and assure you that we are constantly working on enhancing the experience with our products.
Our view
After careful analysis of your case, I can confirm that Revolut app updates are made in order to provide the best security standards, as is stipulated in clause 5 of our https://www.revolut.com/legal/terms/ , and the app only supports official AndroidOS and iOS. I have decided not to uphold your complaint.
Please note that, by not upholding your complaint, we are not dismissing your negative experience in this case. It simply means that, from an objective point of view and to the best of my knowledge, Revolut has not acted unfairly on this occasion.
We are constantly working on improving our services day after day. I can tell you that we are happy having you with us and will use your feedback to provide a better service in the future.
Amk I don't understand clause 5 as they would like us to understand it. This "latest software" doesn't mean "official operating system".
And in fact it is contradicted by the fact the Revolut runs on old, not updated Androids as long as they're "official".
