My new Pixel 9 is suspicious

Kiba

I did another test: I switched to the Alpha channel and installed the OTA update.

I figured that if there was something wrong with my installation of GOS, this might solve the problem.

But no luck. Despite the Alpha update “2025090200,” the Auditor check failed in the same way.

It's frustrating. I'd like to be able to push the test further before returning the phone to find out if it's a bug due to faulty hardware (which would actually be detected by Auditor), but I'm left unsatisfied lol.

linux-dev

Kiba Faulty hardware e.g. memory or cpu usually causes openssl to fail, which results in the Failed to generate key pair error did you use logcat to follow the complete output when running auditor and check for openssl entries?

Kiba

linux-dev I reflashed the phone from my Pixel 6 using the web installer.
The procedure went well, and then again, without touching anything beforehand, I launched Auditor and it crashed.
Following your advice, I tried a logcat at that point. I think I managed to isolate the part in question. I see that it mentions a bug and a component that cannot be found/identified?

Apart from Auditor, the phone doesn't seem to have any particular problems, but I haven't used it much yet (I haven't copied anything onto it yet...).

09-03 14:57:03.195 517 517 E android.hardware.security.keymint-service.citadel: GenerateRkpKey: request failed with status: APP_ERROR_BOGUS_ARGS
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: Failed to generate key. Failed with 1
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: android.os.ServiceSpecificException: GenerateRkpKey: request failed with status: APP_ERROR_BOGUS_ARGS (code 1)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at android.os.Parcel.createExceptionOrNull(Parcel.java:3363)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at android.os.Parcel.createException(Parcel.java:3333)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at android.os.Parcel.readException(Parcel.java:3309)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at android.os.Parcel.readException(Parcel.java:3251)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at android.hardware.security.keymint.IRemotelyProvisionedComponent$Stub$Proxy.generateEcdsaP256KeyPair(IRemotelyProvisionedComponent.java:214)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at com.android.rkpdapp.interfaces.SystemInterface.generateKey(SystemInterface.java:86)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at com.android.rkpdapp.provisioner.Provisioner.generateKeys(Provisioner.java:121)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at com.android.rkpdapp.provisioner.Provisioner.provisionKeys(Provisioner.java:91)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at com.android.rkpdapp.service.RegistrationBinder.fetchGeekAndProvisionKeys(RegistrationBinder.java:157)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at com.android.rkpdapp.service.RegistrationBinder.getKeyWorker(RegistrationBinder.java:120)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at com.android.rkpdapp.service.RegistrationBinder.getKeyThreadWorker(RegistrationBinder.java:244)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at com.android.rkpdapp.service.RegistrationBinder.lambda$getKey$3(RegistrationBinder.java:231)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at com.android.rkpdapp.service.RegistrationBinder.$r8$lambda$3tjqw_fbETEHa8OE8G7aQdQksF8(RegistrationBinder.java:0)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at com.android.rkpdapp.service.RegistrationBinder$$ExternalSyntheticLambda12.run(R8$$SyntheticClass:0)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at java.util.concurrent.Executors$RunnableAdapter.call(Executors.java:524)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at java.util.concurrent.FutureTask.run(FutureTask.java:317)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor.runWorker(ThreadPoolExecutor.java:1156)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor$Worker.run(ThreadPoolExecutor.java:651)
09-03 14:57:03.197 4479 5717 E RkpdSystemInterface: at java.lang.Thread.run(Thread.java:1119)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: Unexpected error provisioning keys
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: android.os.ServiceSpecificException: GenerateRkpKey: request failed with status: APP_ERROR_BOGUS_ARGS (code 1)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at android.os.Parcel.createExceptionOrNull(Parcel.java:3363)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at android.os.Parcel.createException(Parcel.java:3333)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at android.os.Parcel.readException(Parcel.java:3309)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at android.os.Parcel.readException(Parcel.java:3251)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at android.hardware.security.keymint.IRemotelyProvisionedComponent$Stub$Proxy.generateEcdsaP256KeyPair(IRemotelyProvisionedComponent.java:214)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at com.android.rkpdapp.interfaces.SystemInterface.generateKey(SystemInterface.java:86)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at com.android.rkpdapp.provisioner.Provisioner.generateKeys(Provisioner.java:121)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at com.android.rkpdapp.provisioner.Provisioner.provisionKeys(Provisioner.java:91)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at com.android.rkpdapp.service.RegistrationBinder.fetchGeekAndProvisionKeys(RegistrationBinder.java:157)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at com.android.rkpdapp.service.RegistrationBinder.getKeyWorker(RegistrationBinder.java:120)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at com.android.rkpdapp.service.RegistrationBinder.getKeyThreadWorker(RegistrationBinder.java:244)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at com.android.rkpdapp.service.RegistrationBinder.lambda$getKey$3(RegistrationBinder.java:231)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at com.android.rkpdapp.service.RegistrationBinder.$r8$lambda$3tjqw_fbETEHa8OE8G7aQdQksF8(RegistrationBinder.java:0)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at com.android.rkpdapp.service.RegistrationBinder$$ExternalSyntheticLambda12.run(R8$$SyntheticClass:0)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at java.util.concurrent.Executors$RunnableAdapter.call(Executors.java:524)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at java.util.concurrent.FutureTask.run(FutureTask.java:317)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor.runWorker(ThreadPoolExecutor.java:1156)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor$Worker.run(ThreadPoolExecutor.java:651)
09-03 14:57:03.199 4479 5717 E RkpdRegistrationBinder: at java.lang.Thread.run(Thread.java:1119)
09-03 14:57:03.199 1333 1333 E RemoteProvisionSysSvc: RKP error fetching key for client 209476529: ERROR_UNKNOWN: GenerateRkpKey: request failed with status: APP_ERROR_BOGUS_ARGS
09-03 14:57:03.199 513 618 E keystore2: system/security/keystore2/rkpd_client/src/lib.rs:193 - IGetKeyCallback failed: ERROR_UNKNOWN: GenerateRkpKey: request failed with status: APP_ERROR_BOGUS_ARGS
09-03 14:57:03.200 513 535 W keystore2: system/security/keystore2/src/remote_provisioning.rs:97 - Error occurred: system/security/keystore2/rkpd_client/src/lib.rs:194: GetKeyCallback failed: r#ERROR_UNKNOWN "ERROR_UNKNOWN: GenerateRkpKey: request failed with status: APP_ERROR_BOGUS_ARGS"
09-03 14:57:03.200 513 535 W keystore2:
09-03 14:57:03.200 513 535 W keystore2: Caused by:
09-03 14:57:03.200 513 535 W keystore2: Failed to get key: r#ERROR_UNKNOWN
09-03 14:57:03.201 520 537 D libnos_datagram: Calling App 0x02 with params 0x0001
09-03 14:57:03.221 843 1251 W Lyric : device_context.cc:362: NotifyCaptureSessionClose: No OisController found for physical camera RearWide. Status: NOT_FOUND: Failed to find controller by type and camera id(RearWide); Controller with ID: optical image stabilization controller for camera: RearWide not present in device_context
09-03 14:57:03.221 843 1251 W Lyric : device_context.cc:362: NotifyCaptureSessionClose: No OisController found for physical camera RearWideVirtual. Status: NOT_FOUND: Failed to find controller by type and camera id(RearWideVirtual); Controller with ID: optical image stabilization controller for camera: RearWideVirtual not present in device_context
09-03 14:57:03.221 843 1758 I StreamBufferCacheManager: _{StreamBufferCacheManager}: Destroying stream buffer cache manager.
09-03 14:57:03.221 843 5680 I StreamBufferCacheManager: WorkloadThreadLoop: Exiting stream buffer cache manager workload thread.
09-03 14:57:03.221 843 1758 I Lyric : camera_latency_analyzer.cc:99: [CLA] Cam0-Close
09-03 14:57:03.221 843 1758 I Lyric : camera_latency_analyzer.cc:101: [CLA] (Cam0-Close) Flush latency: 72.9414
09-03 14:57:03.221 843 1758 I Lyric : camera_latency_analyzer.cc:101: [CLA] (Cam0-Close) <-- IDLE --> latency: 0.552734
09-03 14:57:03.221 843 1758 I Lyric : camera_latency_analyzer.cc:101: [CLA] (Cam0-Close) Close latency: 137.972
09-03 14:57:03.221 843 1758 I Lyric : camera_latency_analyzer.cc:101: [CLA] (Cam0-Close) Overall latency: 211.476
09-03 14:57:03.221 843 1758 I Lyric : camera_latency_analyzer.cc:101: [CLA] (Cam0-Close) HAL Total latency: 210.91
09-03 14:57:03.222 1019 1019 I CameraLatencyHistogram: Stream 0 dequeueBuffer latency histogram (42) samples:
09-03 14:57:03.222 1019 1019 I CameraLatencyHistogram: 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 inf (max ms)
09-03 14:57:03.222 1019 1019 I CameraLatencyHistogram: 100.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 (%)
09-03 14:57:03.222 1019 1019 I CameraLatencyHistogram: Stream 1 dequeueBuffer latency histogram (42) samples:
09-03 14:57:03.223 1019 1019 I CameraLatencyHistogram: 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 inf (max ms)
09-03 14:57:03.223 1019 1019 I CameraLatencyHistogram: 100.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 (%)
09-03 14:57:03.223 520 537 D libnos_datagram: App 0x02 returning 0x0
09-03 14:57:03.223 1019 1019 I Camera3-Device: disconnectImpl: X
09-03 14:57:03.223 517 517 I android.hardware.security.keymint-service.citadel: Batch attestation requested.
09-03 14:57:03.223 520 537 D libnos_datagram: Calling App 0x02 with params 0x0005
09-03 14:57:03.223 1019 1019 I CameraService: onTorchStatusChangedLocked: Torch status changed for cameraId=0, newStatus=1
09-03 14:57:03.224 2525 2909 D FlashlightController: dispatchAvailabilityChanged(true)
09-03 14:57:03.224 1019 1019 I CameraService: disconnect: Disconnected client for camera 0 for PID 5599
09-03 14:57:03.224 2691 2902 D LyricConfigProviderService: onCameraClosed: cameraID: 0
09-03 14:57:03.225 5599 5654 D DeferrableSurface: use count-1, useCount=0 closed=true x.k0@57e1abb
09-03 14:57:03.225 5599 5654 D DeferrableSurface: Surface no longer in use[total_surfaces=2, used_surfaces=1](x.k0@57e1abb}
09-03 14:57:03.225 5599 5654 D DeferrableSurface: Surface terminated[total_surfaces=1, used_surfaces=1](x.k0@57e1abb}
09-03 14:57:03.225 2691 2901 D PersistentCameraBackgroundServices: Broadcasting action 'com.google.pixel.camera.services.cameraidremapper.action.CAMERA_CLOSED' for camera '0'...
09-03 14:57:03.225 5599 5654 D DeferrableSurface: use count-1, useCount=0 closed=true x.k0@cd68d84
09-03 14:57:03.225 5599 5654 D DeferrableSurface: Surface no longer in use[total_surfaces=1, used_surfaces=0](x.k0@cd68d84}
09-03 14:57:03.225 5599 5599 D SurfaceViewImpl: Safe to release surface.
09-03 14:57:03.225 5599 5654 D DeferrableSurface: Surface terminated[total_surfaces=0, used_surfaces=0](x.k0@cd68d84}
09-03 14:57:03.226 5599 5654 D Camera2CameraImpl: {Camera@bbaace1[id=0]} CameraDevice.onClosed()
09-03 14:57:03.226 5599 5654 D Camera2CameraImpl: {Camera@bbaace1[id=0]} Transitioning camera internal state: CLOSING --> INITIALIZED
09-03 14:57:03.226 5599 5654 D CameraStateRegistry: Recalculating open cameras:
09-03 14:57:03.226 5599 5654 D CameraStateRegistry: Camera State
09-03 14:57:03.226 5599 5654 D CameraStateRegistry: -------------------------------------------------------------------
09-03 14:57:03.226 5599 5654 D CameraStateRegistry: Camera@4f4b660[id=1] UNKNOWN
09-03 14:57:03.226 5599 5654 D CameraStateRegistry: Camera@bbaace1[id=0] CLOSED
09-03 14:57:03.226 5599 5654 D CameraStateRegistry: -------------------------------------------------------------------
09-03 14:57:03.226 5599 5654 D CameraStateRegistry: Open count: 0 (Max allowed: 1)
09-03 14:57:03.226 2691 2901 I PersistentCameraBackgroundServices: Broadcast action 'com.google.pixel.camera.services.cameraidremapper.action.CAMERA_CLOSED' for camera '0'.
09-03 14:57:03.226 5599 5654 D CameraStateMachine: New public camera state CameraState{type=CLOSED, error=null} from CLOSED and null
09-03 14:57:03.226 5599 5654 D CameraStateMachine: Publishing new public camera state CameraState{type=CLOSED, error=null}
09-03 14:57:03.226 2776 3328 I PixelDisplayManager: Request Lbe state 0 req 1, display unique id: local:4619827555876906240
09-03 14:57:03.227 5599 5654 D SyncCaptureSessionImpl: [q.e0@1a2bd77] onClosed()
09-03 14:57:03.227 1333 1544 D OomAdjuster: Not killing cached processes
09-03 14:57:03.228 869 869 D usf_sensor_hal: ambient light: Enter Batch. Period = 100000000, latency = 0.
09-03 14:57:03.229 869 869 D usf_sensor_hal: ambient light: Enter Activate. Enable = 1.
09-03 14:57:03.229 869 1638 I sensor-suez: Vendor atom [id = 100243] reported.
09-03 14:57:03.230 1134 1134 D AOC : A3:MSG: usf_sensor.cc, 1774: USF: Received start sampling request for TMD3733 Ambient Light (active:2).
09-03 14:57:03.231 869 1638 I sensor-suez: Vendor atom [id = 100242] reported.
09-03 14:57:03.231 869 1638 I sensor-suez: Vendor atom [id = 100243] reported.
09-03 14:57:03.231 869 1638 I sensor-suez: Vendor atom [id = 100245] reported.
09-03 14:57:03.232 2776 3328 I PixelDisplayManager: Request Lbe state 1 req 1, display unique id: local:4619827555876906240
09-03 14:57:03.232 526 609 I hwc-display: atc enable=1 (mode=normal, pending off=false)
09-03 14:57:03.232 526 609 I hwc-display: Lbe state 1
09-03 14:57:03.233 2776 3328 I PixelDisplayManager: setLbeState to 1
09-03 14:57:03.234 520 537 D libnos_datagram: App 0x02 returning 0x0
09-03 14:57:03.235 520 537 D libnos_datagram: Calling App 0x02 with params 0x001a
09-03 14:57:03.239 520 537 D libnos_datagram: App 0x02 returning 0x0
09-03 14:57:03.239 520 520 D libnos_datagram: Calling App 0x02 with params 0x001b
09-03 14:57:03.263 520 520 D libnos_datagram: App 0x02 returning 0x0
09-03 14:57:03.263 517 517 E android.hardware.security.keymint-service.citadel: FinishAttestKey: UNKNOWN_ERROR
09-03 14:57:03.264 513 535 E keystore2: system/security/keystore2/src/error.rs:183 - system/security/keystore2/src/security_level.rs:680
09-03 14:57:03.264 513 535 E keystore2:
09-03 14:57:03.264 513 535 E keystore2: Caused by:
09-03 14:57:03.264 513 535 E keystore2: 0: system/security/keystore2/src/security_level.rs:674: While generating without a provided attestation key and params: [KeyParameter { tag: r#KEY_SIZE, value: Integer(256) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#ALGORITHM, value: Algorithm(r#EC) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#EC_CURVE, value: EcCurve(r#P_256) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#PURPOSE, value: KeyPurpose(r#ATTEST_KEY) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#DIGEST, value: Digest(r#SHA_2_256) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#NO_AUTH_REQUIRED, value: BoolValue(true) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#ACTIVE_DATETIME, value: DateTime(1756903922501) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#CERTIFICATE_NOT_AFTER, value: DateTime(2461449600000) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#CERTIFICATE_NOT_BEFORE, value: DateTime(0) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#CERTIFICATE_SERIAL, value: Blob([1]) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#CERTIFICATE_SUBJECT, value: Blob([48, 31, 49, 29, 48, 27, 6, 3, 85, 4, 3, 19, 20, 65, 110, 100, 114, 111, 105, 100, 32, 75, 101, 121, 115, 116, 111, 114, 101, 32, 75, 101, 121]) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#ATTESTATION_CHALLENGE, value: Blob([104, 102, 251, 107, 243, 30, 35, 196, 93, 84, 134, 243, 36, 176, 95, 201, 230, 238, 41, 240, 135, 145, 120, 128, 179, 101, 231, 226, 94, 231, 60, 175]) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#CREATION_DATETIME, value: DateTime(1756904223200) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#ATTESTATION_APPLICATION_ID, value: Blob([48, 68, 49, 30, 48, 28, 4, 23, 97, 112, 112, 46, 97, 116, 116, 101, 115, 116, 97, 116, 105, 111, 110, 46, 97, 117, 100, 105, 116, 111, 114, 2, 1, 89, 49, 34, 4, 32, 153, 14, 4, 240, 134, 75, 25, 241, 79, 132, 224, 228, 50, 247, 163, 147, 242, 151, 171, 16, 90, 34, 193, 225, 177, 11, 68, 42, 74, 98, 196, 44]) }].
09-03 14:57:03.264 513 535 E keystore2: 1: Error::Km(r#UNKNOWN_ERROR)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: attestation generation error
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: java.io.IOException: java.security.ProviderException: Failed to generate key pair.
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at T0.r.f(Unknown Source:18)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at T0.r.g(Unknown Source:214)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at T0.b.run(Unknown Source:16)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at java.util.concurrent.Executors$RunnableAdapter.call(Executors.java:524)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at java.util.concurrent.FutureTask.run(FutureTask.java:317)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor.runWorker(ThreadPoolExecutor.java:1156)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor$Worker.run(ThreadPoolExecutor.java:651)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at java.lang.Thread.run(Thread.java:1119)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: Caused by: java.security.ProviderException: Failed to generate key pair.
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at android.security.keystore2.AndroidKeyStoreKeyPairGeneratorSpi.generateKeyPair(AndroidKeyStoreKeyPairGeneratorSpi.java:712)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at java.security.KeyPairGenerator$Delegate.generateKeyPair(KeyPairGenerator.java:750)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at T0.r.f(Unknown Source:11)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: ... 7 more
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: Caused by: android.security.KeyStoreException: Unknown error (internal Keystore code: -1000 message: system/security/keystore2/src/security_level.rs:680
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity:
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: Caused by:
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: 0: system/security/keystore2/src/security_level.rs:674: While generating without a provided attestation key and params: [KeyParameter { tag: r#KEY_SIZE, value: Integer(256) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#ALGORITHM, value: Algorithm(r#EC) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#EC_CURVE, value: EcCurve(r#P_256) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#PURPOSE, value: KeyPurpose(r#ATTEST_KEY) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#DIGEST, value: Digest(r#SHA_2_256) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#NO_AUTH_REQUIRED, value: BoolValue(true) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#ACTIVE_DATETIME, value: DateTime(1756903922501) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#CERTIFICATE_NOT_AFTER, value: DateTime(2461449600000) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#CERTIFICATE_NOT_BEFORE, value: DateTime(0) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#CERTIFICATE_SERIAL, value: Blob([1]) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#CERTIFICATE_SUBJECT, value: Blob([48, 31, 49, 29, 48, 27, 6, 3, 85, 4, 3, 19, 20, 65, 110, 100, 114, 111, 105, 100, 32, 75, 101, 121, 115, 116, 111, 114, 101, 32, 75, 101, 121]) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#ATTESTATION_CHALLENGE, value: Blob([104, 102, 251, 107, 243, 30, 35, 196, 93, 84, 134, 243, 36, 176, 95, 201, 230, 238, 41, 240, 135, 145, 120, 128, 179, 101, 231, 226, 94, 231, 60, 175]) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#CREATION_DATETIME, value: DateTime(1756904223200) }, KeyParameter { tag: r#ATTESTATION_APPLICATION_ID, value: Blob([48, 68, 49, 30, 48, 28, 4, 23, 97, 112, 112, 46, 97, 116, 116, 101, 115, 116, 97, 116, 105, 111, 110, 46, 97, 117, 100, 105, 116, 111, 114, 2, 1, 89, 49, 34, 4, 32, 153, 14, 4, 240, 134, 75, 25, 241, 79, 132, 224, 228, 50, 247, 163, 147, 242, 151, 171, 16, 90, 34, 193, 225, 177, 11, 68, 42, 74, 98, 196, 44]) }].
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: 1: Error::Km(r#UNKNOWN_ERROR)) (public error code: 10 internal Keystore code: -1000)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at android.security.KeyStore2.getKeyStoreException(KeyStore2.java:428)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at android.security.KeyStoreSecurityLevel.handleExceptions(KeyStoreSecurityLevel.java:58)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at android.security.KeyStoreSecurityLevel.generateKey(KeyStoreSecurityLevel.java:149)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: at android.security.keystore2.AndroidKeyStoreKeyPairGeneratorSpi.generateKeyPair(AndroidKeyStoreKeyPairGeneratorSpi.java:699)
09-03 14:57:03.265 5599 5713 E AttestationActivity: ... 9 more
09-03 14:57:03.532 1037 5521 D AidlBufferPool: bufferpool2 0x100ce4c19df3e68 : 0(0 size) total buffers - 0(0 size) used buffers - 124/136 (recycle/alloc) - 23/266 (fetch/transfer)
09-03 14:57:03.532 1037 5521 D AidlBufferPoolAcc: evictor expired: 1, evicted: 1
09-03 14:57:03.533 1111 2004 D AidlBufferPool: bufferpool2 0xc00d644f1657968 : 0(0 size) total buffers - 0(0 size) used buffers - 123/131 (recycle/alloc) - 8/130 (fetch/transfer)
09-03 14:57:03.533 1111 2004 D AidlBufferPoolAcc: evictor expired: 2, evicted: 1
09-03 14:57:03.659 1333 1483 I DisplayDeviceRepository: Display device changed render timings: "Écran intégré", renderFrameRate=120.00002, presentationDeadlineNanos=11500000, appVsyncOffsetNanos=6233332, frameRateOverrides=[{uid=10131 frameRateHz=120.00002}, {uid=10150 frameRateHz=60.00001}]
09-03 14:57:03.764 520 533 D libnos_datagram: Calling App 0x00 with params 0x0200
09-03 14:57:03.794 520 533 D libnos_datagram: App 0x00 returning 0x0

de0u

Kiba If the phone was sold as new but the battery has 125 cycles, that's fraudulent. I would return it instantly for that reason alone. In addition, something seems to be wrong with the hardware keystore, not a good sign. Maybe over time other things will go wrong too! Maybe the screen isn't a real Pixel screen, but some knock-off. Maybe the previous owner used to drop it.

I would absolutely send it back.

Kiba

de0u I sent a complaint to Rakuten yesterday and received a response a few minutes ago stating that the seller had 10 days to respond.

After multiple attempts, I also think there may be a hardware issue and I suspect that this phone has not revealed all its secrets.

Obviously, I needed a phone urgently and this is not good news for me...

de0u

Kiba Let us know how it goes...

Kiba

A quick update on my problem:

I flashed the phone with the official Google ROM (stock OS) and Auditor still fails to perform its check, returning the same error. So it's probably a hardware issue, but I think Auditor should be a little more precise.

And I'm really surprised that you can find phones on the market that are so “altered” that they fail Auditor. I thought this only applied to certain attacks targeting important people, but not just refurbished phones.

On top of that, the seller Rakuten is doing everything it can to avoid getting involved. They are slow to respond to me, and they ask me for tons of paperwork and photos.
At first, they apologized for the delivery error and gave me a procedure for lost or damaged packages... (???) but there's no way to contact them except through standard forms. I really don't recommend this store.
They're pressuring me to close the case by September 16, otherwise they say it will be too late, and they keep asking me for different things. 😒

Pocketstar

Kiba I would report them to the authorities as well; selling a used phone as new, even going as far as providing a fake box is a deliberate attempt on covering it up, the box itself (and the phone) can serve as evidence.
Also make a screenshot of the page where they claim it is new before they remove that evidence!! And do not toss the receipt out.
Now they also seem to stall in order to cheat you out of your warranty period.
If they do not accept the phone back, keep the box (and receipt) as evidence though, best not to toss it out, the box should always state the amount of memory, so it is a knock-off packache as well.

Marken

I had same issue with Rakuten.
A phone sold as new but reconditioned. It's happen often, in my country is a fraud. It take time to refund with a lot of bad faith but they did!

My advice never buy electronic on market place. Good luck!

chinook

Marken I bought a lot of the 2nd hand hardware on eBay (because of where I live), and not even once I had an issue with the electronic devices purchased here.

I wouldn't buy off Gumtree or Facebook though - precisely because of the buyer protections I have. If I buy outside of the reasonably trusted places I always pay with the credit card (ideally amex), as they offer strong enough purchase protections.

Kiba

Rakuten finally accepted the return, and I took the opportunity to order from “belsimpel,” the site recommended by PocketStar. Thanks to him.

Ordered at 5:00 p.m. and received the next day at 9:00 a.m., perfect.

I received a brand new phone with zero cycles, first used on September 17, which passed Auditor without error.

I compared the two phones and on the refurbished one, the “fastboot” mode displays “NOS Production: NO.”

I can't find much information on the internet, but I see that this could be a sign of tampering, and I think that's what causes Auditor to fail.

I wonder if the phone was a phone with a blocked OEM unlock that was unlocked in an inappropriate manner... Hence the message in fastboot and the fact that I received it already unlocked.

Thank you all for your help. 😃

chinook If I buy outside of the reasonably trusted places I always pay with the credit card (ideally amex)

I paid with Amex on Rakuten, and my last resort was indeed to get them involved. 😊

n3t_admin

Kiba “NOS Production: NO.”

This further hints at my suspicion, that this was a demo device.

« Previous Page