Can't use my passkeys that are stored in Proton Pass

Lukas

Am I the only one who can't use passkeys that are stored on Proton Pass? Could someone please test this out? I'm on a Pixel 6a, all the channels are set to stable.

fid02

Lukas Works fine for me. What are the symptoms of the "can't use" issue? Are there any error messages being displayed?

Also, check the following: Settings > Passwords, passkeys & autofill > set Proton Pass as a provider

Vanadium > Settings > Autofill Options > Set to "Use other providers".

Reboot your phone if it still doesn't work.

Lukas

fid02 Works fine for me. What are the symptoms of the "can't use" issue? Are there any error messages being displayed?

It just ignores the fact that Proton Pass exists. It forces me to use Google Password Manager. My configuration is correct, I also tried reinstalling Proton Pass, etc.

Lukas

fid02 Works fine for me.

What version of Vanadium are you using? Mine is: 128.0.6613.88.1

fid02

Lukas I assume that it looks like this: https://ibb.co/98hFVhh
Alt text: the passkey sign-in window showing "Google Password Manager" as a headline, the name of the passkey and its credentials, and then the password manager in question.

If it says "Proton Pass" anywhere in that dialog, it's using Proton Pass and not Google Password Manager. The UI is coming from Play Services and is confusing you into believing that you are using passkeys saved to your Google account.

Lukas

fid02 I have been using Proton Pass for months, everything was fine. I know how things look and work, this is definently not user error.

fid02

Lukas I'm not sure I understand your reply. I was not suggesting it was user error. On the contrary, I was criticizing Google for a confusing UI design.

If you are not willing to provide details on how the screen actually looks on your side, or whether or not it's including "Proton Pass" in the text, I can't help you. How is anyone supposed to assist you simply based on the information that "my configuration is correct"?

Lukas

fid02 https://ibb.co/F6ZVyR4

Everything worked fine until Vanadium got updated today in the morning.

fid02

Lukas https://ibb.co/F6ZVyR4

Interesting.

Lukas What version of Vanadium are you using? Mine is: 128.0.6613.88.1

I'm on the same Vanadium version.

Do you have any flags set in chrome://flags? If so, could you please list which ones?

And which version of Proton Pass are you on? I'm on version 1.24.4.

Lukas

fid02 Do you have any flags set in chrome://flags? If so, could you please list which ones?

I just did a factory reset and still have the issue, which proves that the issue is with the latest Vanadium update.

fid02 And which version of Proton Pass are you on? I'm on version 1.24.4.

I'm on the same version too.

fid02

Lukas

gwr

I have managed to reproduce the issue. Which version of Play Services are you on? To get the version, go to App Store > Google Play Services > look at Installed version

gwr

I have the same issue. I just installed GrapheneOS today, and I'm on the Pixel 9. I wanted to use Ente Auth, and it uses the website to verify the passkey. The passkey interaction is just not working. Even with Chrome 125 flags enabled, and the "Use Third-party passkeys" option on, it still wouldn't delete it. I tried disabling and enabling back Proton Pass passwords/passkeys permission, but this didn't change anything.

Lukas

fid02 24.22.13

fid02

Lukas 24.22.13

That's the version where the bug is reproducible for me. If you are comfortable with using a version of Play Services that is not as widely deployed or tested yet, you can try upgrading to the version in the Alpha channel in App Store, and see if that solves the issue. To do that, go to App Store > Google Play Services > tap the three dots upper-right corner > Release channel > Alpha. Then install the update.

It might work with the version from the Beta channel as well but I haven't tested that yet (you are welcome to try that).

fid02

Lukas

There is a new version of Play Services (stable release) in App Store right now. To me, it seems to resolve the issue.

gwr

fid02

fid02 using a version of Play Services

I don't use Play Services, at least I haven't enabled anything to do so !

Carlos-Anso

gwr
Have a look at https://discuss.grapheneos.org/d/12019-passkeys-as-mfa-on-grapheneos-a-guide

fid02

gwr You need Play Services for practically most passkey (and FIDO) functionality. All you need to do is install Google Play Services from App Store, undo the flags you set in Vanadium, then enable your password manager in Settings > Passwords, passkeys and autofill.
This is all assuming that you want/need to use Play Services in the first place.

gwr

I tested with Mull, and it worked on first try though. (BTW, why can't I edit my comment ?°

gwr

fid02

fid02 You need Play Services for practically most passkey (and FIDO) functionality.

Weirdly enough, Proton Pass (F-Droid) + Mull support passkeys well.

fid02 assuming that you want/need to use Play Services in the first place.

For now, I have managed to do without it. I have just had one very crucial apps that wasn't working, so I set up a work profile and it worked fine (do work profile has GMS enabled ?).