brook In this sentence I see no Security improvements for me.
But it is not about you. It is about the whole Android user base.
brook How come? If you forgot your Veracrypt password you are 100% screwed, no booting to liveusb would help you.
I made it clear that in a situation of forgetting my password to my Windows account, the actual system disk is unencrypted. A Windows account password usually doesn't encrypt disk contents.
Why are you talking about Veracrypt? Do you really believe that most people use Veracrypt? Or password managers? Or any disk encryption software that requires manual setup?
brook It is NOT secure feature, it's the opposite, right?
I see your point about the feature putting users who cannot hide their pin entry at risk. And I am inclined to agree that having the option to delay – but perhaps not disable – pin entry reminders would be a good feature. But your responses lack any kind of nuance. The feature clearly has properties that ticks several boxes regarding the concept of security. The fact that you personally don't see it as a security feature, and that you personally see it as threatening the sensitive data on your device, does not nullify any security aspect. You also haven't considered that a lot of people are able to hide their pin from shoulder surfers without problems.
On your argument about leaving finger marks. These marks are left everywhere on the screen. Do you have any empirical evidence that forensic examination of fingerprint marks have led to the discovery of someone's unlock credentials?
And on your repeated point about shoulder surfing. I suspect that a lot of people simply raise their phone so close to their face while entering their pin that the risk of someone looking at their screen is very improbable.
Again on your concern about someone examining your fingerprint marks. GrapheneOS has a PIN scrambling feature which you can enable.
brook Vast majority of GrapheneOS users have to enter their passwords at kind-of-random moments due to this problem. And BECAUSE OF THAT they use 4 digits PINs.
You seem so sure in this assertion that I think it's reasonable to ask you to provide evidence of it. In my view it's a very thin argument. Why would people reduce their pin from the recommended 6 digits to 4 digits? Because of time consumption? Because every 48 hours they will waste barely an extra second by having to press two extra digits?
brook Yes, people are not eager to complain because entering 1111 pin is tolerable to them. So, not many posts on forum. Why this pin? See #1.
Dismissing the fact that barely anyone is raising this topic on the forum appears as though you are not at all keen to consider the possibility that most people might not have a problem with the pin amnesia prevention feature. A lot of people frequently post complaints on this forum (in a similar style of writing that you seem to have adopted). "Not many posts on this forum": from my unhealthy amount of reading on this forum over nearly two years, I have never seen a single post about someone reducing their pin complexity because of the pin amnesia prevention feature.
brook Can you compare the difficulty of porting system to A16 and just adding a toggle in settings to disable this insecure timeout? My proposal is like 100 times easier to implement and 98% of users would benifit from it. Or 1000 times easier, one-day task for developer that knows this system, like Daniel Micay.
This discussion is becoming increasingly arrogant. Are you Daniel Micay? Are you a developer with familiarity with AOSP code? How do you know that this is a one-day task to implement and test across several devices?
brook make me speak too harsh, than I probably should.
This I definitely agree with.
But seems kind of strange that you still are not considering using a reminder app to remind you, given the alarm you express at the forced pin entry feature. I know that you don't consider it a solution, but at least it seems like a workaround that will clearly benefit you.