Google photo network problem

[deleted]

Correlation is not the same as causation

jufstp

treequell Photos cannot be edited offline after a certain time offline. Please read the message again.

jufstp

treequell You have a very expeditious way of solving problems. You don't even try to reproduce the problem.

jufstp

treequell I never said I couldn't view photos, I said I couldn't edit photos. When I click on edit there's a loading page that spins around in a vacuum.

jufstp

treequell I therefore conclude that the grapheneos internet authorization leaks the data. If you don't believe me you are free to reproduce.

[deleted]

jufstp you have an interesting way of thinking. If you don't trust Android permission system, how come you are still using it? When I say something is black, it can not be white. When you turn the BT off, it is off, not on. And when you revoke network, you can't get past the fence.

jufstp

[deleted] Reproduce the problem. Thank you.

jufstp

[deleted] Disabling network authorization with a sim card doesn't change the way the application works. Remove the sim card and the application doesn't work the same way. You're the researchers, not me. I'm just telling you what I think the problem is. And telling me to stop using Android isn't a solution.

[deleted]

jufstp I have, app works fine editing with no network. But I only just installed it. Unless it is intended functionality of the app to reconnect to internet after a period of time and reducing usability which you can do diddly squat about. So unless you use it the way it is, look for an alternative. Or try reinstalling, it might help. I am in love with this forum, but sometimes I hate it.

jufstp

[deleted] Wait 2 days without network before drawing a conclusion. I'll leave it at that, I think I understand the mentality. Taking people for idiots like that you have no problem with your operating system. As for me, I'll leave it at that and make a video to show the problem. Hopefully a developer will watch it. Have a nice day!

[deleted]

jufstp you need to calm down my friend. Remaining in the territory that makes you feel uncomfortable is not good for your well-being. This issue is marked as solved and on that I trust the mod. Honestly, look for an alternative (like Aves) if Google Photos don't work the way you want.

treequell

I don't follow how the app removing the ability to edit photos because you haven't been connected to the internet means that it is able to connect to the network? It's not the behavior you observed that puzzles me, but that you've leapt to such a conclusion.

jufstp

treequell
-Google photo with network authorization disabled but sim card installed: everything works.

-Same thing without sim card or wifi: photo viewing works but not editing.

I'm very surprised at the speed with which you've labelled this as solved.
I don't have a github account and I don't know how it works, so I'll let you decide how to proceed. If you label it as solved, that's it.

treequell

I presume Google Photos must give you a period of time after installing the app to allow you touch up photos locally on the device, before asking you to connect to the internet. The touch up photos is still done locally on the device whether the app has a network connection or not.

[deleted]

jufstp Google Photos doesn't works for edit/share/delete if you haven't installed GSF.
If Google Services are installed you may use full GPhotos without any user and without Network connection

[deleted]

[deleted] just a little observation. I do not use Google Play Services, all Google Photos functions worked with/without network. During photo editing session Tracker Control hasn't picked up any outgoing network activity.

[deleted]

[deleted] I have installed yesterday in a profile without Sandboxes Google Play Services installed and the app doesn't action to Edit/Delete or Share but working fine in main profile, with Sandboxed GFS installed. Maybe other difference that I did not take into account

Note 1: Here (https://www.xda-developers.com/huawei-app-alternatives/) also writting that GPhotos doesn't works without GSF, but maybe outdated info
Note 2: GCalendar do not opens without GFS also

treequell

I'll agree that I misunderstood you in the first place. I'll mark this as unsolved for now.

Diagnosing behavior of the Google apps is complicated by the fact that many of them including Google Photos have functionalities which are dependent on other Google apps.

In any case, I don't believe Google Photos requires an internet connection to edit photos.

jufstp

treequell thanks. I think it's the Google play sandboxes that are the problem, Google photo has to communicate with them via IPC but as the play services have absolutely no internet connection for some time they remove functionality from other applications. This means, in my opinion, that network authorization can be bypassed. This is just my opinion, I'm not a security researcher. Maybe that's why the devs are working on a system to cut off IPC communications.