Speeduser7533 its not a good look if you intentionally implement it, but only after it has been exposed to public they attempt to patch things up.

    bootloader

    Thank you for revealing and discussing this issue in Proton email (and others) apps.

    FWIW, I've been quite satisfied using Vanadium to access my various Proton online storage(s), and AFAICT Google is not involved.

    Also Vanadium seems the MOST trustworthy and secure (hardening) web app around. Even if Proton modifies its' apps, they won't be as secure as Vanadium. So for me, the question becomes, how badly do I need push notifications?

    Don't need them.

    Also, the quick-reply business crowd seems to be moving to SMS - which of course has NO privacy - but significant security thanks to GOS auditing and hardening.

    (FWIW this same reasoning applies to my banking - I use Vanadium, and not some poorly-written bank app)

    Just suggesting that you do not abandon Proton web storage(s). HTH.

        Unfortunately, I do need notifs for my emails :/

        Annoying.

          rdns dev here

          GlytchMeister definitely interested in a guide... And even more interested in a "RethinkDNS for Dummies" sort of guide.

          I put an ad-hoc one on our subreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/rethinkdns/comments/12ta9zo/configure_app_for_optimal_use/ / mirror: https://archive.is/Krcoh

          The gist is, allow only what you trust.

          1. From Configure -> Firewall -> Universal firewall rules, turn ON
            • Block when device is locked
            • Block newly installed apps by default
            • (if you're feeling particularly adventurous) Block when DNS is bypassed
          2. Go to Configure -> Apps, then tap on the wifi and mobile icons 🛜📶 to block all apps.
            • Search for apps you use (for me, its 7 apps of the over 400 installed), and either Bypass Universal them or Isolate them.
              • If you Isolate the app, you'll have to set up trust / allow rules for domains or IPs, over a period of time. Pretty time consuming, but once setup, it works flawlessly.
              • Bypass Universal an app named Google Play services, which is usually responsible for Push Notifications / Gaming / Backups / Payments and other such functionalities apps installed from the Play Store depend on, without which they usually don't work.
          3. From Configure -> DNS, choose or setup your favourite DNS provider. I prefer Oblivious DNS over HTTPS endpoints but there aren't many. You can also leave the default DNS settings as-is; or...
            • Turn ON Advanced DNS filtering (which is experimental and may cause connectivity issues), to make sure domain to IP address mapping isn't polluted. For example, when multiple domain names (youtube.com, mtalk.google.com, googleapis.com) may point to a same set of IP addresses (all owned by Google and hence may be used interchangeably), the Stats and per-app domain rules may behave in funny ways. With Advanced DNS filtering (which has other bugs) will possibly not.
            • Turn ON Prevent DNS leaks to trap apps sending DNS traffic themselves. This setting may break notifications for some apps.
            • Turn ON Never proxy DNS if you face connectivity issues with using your preferred DNS upstream with an egress proxy setup within Rethink (SOCKS5, Tor, or WireGuard).
          4. In Configure -> Network, you may
            • Set Choose IP version to Auto and turn ON Perform connectivity checks (if you're on networks that perform 4to6 translations).
              • Turn ON Use all available networks, if you'd want Rethink to use either wifi or mobile at the same time. Make sure you've got enough juice on mobile data, as it is usually prohibitively expensive in some countries.
              • Leave everything else in there turned OFF, unless you like living dangerously.
          5. Optionally setup WireGuard from Configure -> Proxy -> Setup WireGuard, either in Simple mode (single WireGuard, all apps routed through it, unless Bypass app from all proxies is set for that particular app) or Advanced mode (multiple WireGuards, split tunneled, manually choose apps to route through them).

          Rethink has grown to be a Frankenstein monster and I get a lot of emails on how difficult it is to use, but someday someone from the community will write one true guide to setup Rethink so I can point everyone to it.

              ignoramous THANK YOU for putting the time and energy into posting this message! I haven't yet had a chance to read and absorb all that you have given us here - it is tech heavy - but it is clearly an important read even for us who rely upon our VPNs to provide DNS service which filters badware and adware! Thanks Again!

                • [deleted]

                • Post #56
                • Edited

                Hi! ignoramous Could you please explain the reasoning behind locking local DNS filtering in Advanced proxy mode? My friend recently pointed out that Rethink's advanced proxy mode forces to use an external, non-proxy DNS, which defeats the whole purpose of VPN.

                    I'm confused, are you saying that if we use the proton mail with our graphenos phone google can track us?

                    ignoramous

                    OK... So...

                    Uh.

                    What stuff can I use alongside the Mullvad App? I don't want to use wireguard and non-mullvad DNS because Mullvad has lockdown and always-on, and using non-mullvad DNS makes my fingerprint more unique.

                    I really just want to use RDNS to block apps like discord and proton mail from connecting to anything except what they strictly need to connect to in order to function.

                    Aka, I only want the local, on-device filtering, and I don't know enough about anything to know what is local and what will mess up the Mullvad App.

                        GlytchMeister don't want to use wireguard and non-mullvad DNS because Mullvad has lockdown and always-on, and using non-mullvad DNS makes my fingerprint more unique.

                        Lockdown and always on can be done in the system VPN settings. And Mullvad DNS can be added to the wireguard config.

                          • [deleted]

                          • Post #60

                          bootloader

                          It appears that only the ProtonMail app uses Firebase.

                          Proton Mail - ProtonMail-4.0.14_9270.apk

                          Services - ProtonMail-4.0.14_9270.apk
                          androidx.appcompat.app.AppLocalesMetadataHolderService
                          ch.protonmail.android.mailnotifications.data.remote.fcm.PMFirebaseMessagingService
                          com.google.firebase.components.ComponentDiscoveryService
                          com.google.firebase.messaging.FirebaseMessagingService
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.SystemAlarmService
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemjob.SystemJobService
                          androidx.work.impl.foreground.SystemForegroundService
                          androidx.room.MultiInstanceInvalidationService
                          com.google.android.datatransport.runtime.backends.TransportBackendDiscovery
                          com.google.android.datatransport.runtime.scheduling.jobscheduling.JobInfoSchedulerService

                          Receivers- ProtonMail-4.0.14_9270.apk
                          ch.protonmail.android.mailnotifications.data.local.PushNotificationActionsBroadcastReceiver
                          ch.protonmail.android.mailsettings.presentation.settings.autolock.broadcastreceiver.TimeSetBroadcastReceiver
                          me.proton.core.notification.presentation.deeplink.DeeplinkBroadcastReceiver
                          com.google.firebase.iid.FirebaseInstanceIdReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.utils.ForceStopRunnable$BroadcastReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$BatteryChargingProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$BatteryNotLowProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$StorageNotLowProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$NetworkStateProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.RescheduleReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxyUpdateReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.diagnostics.DiagnosticsReceiver
                          androidx.profileinstaller.ProfileInstallReceiver
                          com.google.android.datatransport.runtime.scheduling.jobscheduling.AlarmManagerSchedulerBroadcastReceiver

                          Providers - ProtonMail-4.0.14_9270.apk
                          androidx.startup.InitializationProvider
                          com.google.firebase.provider.FirebaseInitProvider
                          io.sentry.android.core.SentryPerformanceProvider
                          leakcanary.internal.PlumberInstaller
                          ####################################

                          ProtonCalendar-Android.apk

                          Services - ProtonCalendar-Android.apk
                          me.proton.android.calendar.CalendarWidgetRemoteViewsService
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.SystemAlarmService
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemjob.SystemJobService
                          androidx.work.impl.foreground.SystemForegroundService
                          androidx.room.MultiInstanceInvalidationService
                          com.google.android.gms.auth.api.signin.RevocationBoundService
                          com.google.android.datatransport.runtime.backends.TransportBackendDiscovery
                          com.google.android.datatransport.runtime.scheduling.jobscheduling.JobInfoSchedulerService

                          Receivers - ProtonCalendar-Android.apk
                          me.proton.android.calendar.ProtonCalendarBroadcastReceiver
                          me.proton.android.calendar.CalendarWidget
                          me.proton.core.notification.presentation.deeplink.DeeplinkBroadcastReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.utils.ForceStopRunnable$BroadcastReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$BatteryChargingProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$BatteryNotLowProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$StorageNotLowProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$NetworkStateProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.RescheduleReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxyUpdateReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.diagnostics.DiagnosticsReceiver
                          androidx.profileinstaller.ProfileInstallReceiver
                          com.google.android.datatransport.runtime.scheduling.jobscheduling.AlarmManagerSchedulerBroadcastReceiver

                          Providers - ProtonCalendar-Android.apk
                          androidx.startup.InitializationProvider
                          io.sentry.android.core.SentryPerformanceProvider
                          ################################################

                          Proton Drive

                          Services - Proton Drive
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.SystemAlarmService
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemjob.SystemJobService
                          androidx.work.impl.foreground.SystemForegroundService
                          androidx.room.MultiInstanceInvalidationService
                          com.google.android.datatransport.runtime.backends.TransportBackendDiscovery
                          com.google.android.datatransport.runtime.scheduling.jobscheduling.JobInfoSchedulerService

                          Receivers - Proton Drive
                          me.proton.android.drive.receiver.NotificationBroadcastReceiver
                          me.proton.core.notification.presentation.deeplink.DeeplinkBroadcastReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.utils.ForceStopRunnable$BroadcastReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$BatteryChargingProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$BatteryNotLowProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$StorageNotLowProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$NetworkStateProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.RescheduleReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxyUpdateReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.diagnostics.DiagnosticsReceiver
                          androidx.profileinstaller.ProfileInstallReceiver
                          com.google.android.datatransport.runtime.scheduling.jobscheduling.AlarmManagerSchedulerBroadcastReceiver

                          Providers - Proton Drive
                          androidx.startup.InitializationProvider
                          androidx.core.content.FileProvider
                          me.proton.core.drive.documentsprovider.data.DriveDocumentsProvider
                          me.proton.core.drive.documentsprovider.data.DriveFileProvider
                          io.sentry.android.core.SentryInitProvider
                          io.sentry.android.core.SentryPerformanceProvider
                          leakcanary.internal.PlumberInstaller
                          ####################################

                          Proton VPN - ProtonVPN-5.3.93.0.apk

                          Services - ProtonVPN-5.3.93.0.apk
                          com.protonvpn.android.vpn.wireguard.WireguardWrapperService
                          com.protonvpn.android.vpn.openvpn.OpenVPNWrapperService
                          com.wireguard.android.backend.GoBackend$VpnService
                          com.protonvpn.android.components.QuickTileService
                          com.protonvpn.android.ui.settings.AppInfoService
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.SystemAlarmService
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemjob.SystemJobService
                          androidx.work.impl.foreground.SystemForegroundService
                          androidx.room.MultiInstanceInvalidationService

                          Receivers - ProtonVPN-5.3.93.0.apk
                          com.protonvpn.android.OnUpdateReceiver
                          com.protonvpn.android.notifications.NotificationActionReceiver
                          com.protonvpn.android.quicktile.QuickTileActionReceiver
                          me.proton.core.notification.presentation.deeplink.DeeplinkBroadcastReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.utils.ForceStopRunnable$BroadcastReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$BatteryChargingProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$BatteryNotLowProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$StorageNotLowProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxy$NetworkStateProxy
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.RescheduleReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.background.systemalarm.ConstraintProxyUpdateReceiver
                          androidx.work.impl.diagnostics.DiagnosticsReceiver
                          androidx.profileinstaller.ProfileInstallReceiver

                          Providers - ProtonVPN-5.3.93.0.apk
                          androidx.core.content.FileProvider
                          androidx.startup.InitializationProvider
                          io.sentry.android.core.SentryPerformanceProvider
                          ################################################

                            • [deleted]

                            • Post #63

                            mmmm

                            The calendar app does not appear to use Firebase.

                                [deleted] Neither does Drive but both Calendar and Drive have google mentions in the lists kindly provided by CyberAU above. Are they somehow different than Firebase?

                                    • [deleted]

                                    • Post #65

                                    MotherShipton

                                    Firebase Cloud Messaging (FCM) - "Using FCM, you can notify a client app that new email or other data is available to sync." Reference: https://firebase.google.com/docs/cloud-messaging/

                                    If Proton email notifications are only point-to-point encrypted, I suspect it would be possible for Google to read the content of the notifications. Thus my previous question:
                                    Is Proton notification data end-to-end encrypted or only point-to-point encrypted?

                                    • mmmm replied to this.

                                        newbie24689 For now, I am happy to uninstall the Mail and Drive apps and revert to using Vanadium (which I also have used when I need to access my bank). I never used Proton notifications and have no Google services installed so this is disappointing to find that Proton have this in their apps. If they are good to their word and remove this in the future, I shall reinstall them. I suppose that I am fortunate in that I find that convenience is a luxury rather then a necessity in my life.